|
By Emma Dall, Taproot Therapy Clinical Trainee
Have you ever left a conversation and immediately started replaying everything you said? Maybe you wonder if your joke came across the wrong way, if you talked too much, or if the other person noticed how nervous you felt. You might find yourself revisiting a small interaction hours or even days later, searching for something you could have said differently. If this sounds familiar, you're not alone. Many people find themselves overthinking conversations, especially when they care about how others perceive them. While reflecting on our interactions can sometimes be helpful, getting stuck in a cycle of second-guessing can leave us feeling anxious, embarrassed, or unsure of ourselves long after a conversation has ended. Why Do We Replay Conversations in Our Heads? Our brains are constantly trying to make sense of the world around us, including our social interactions. We naturally want to feel accepted, understood, and connected to others. When a conversation feels uncertain, our minds may try to fill in the gaps by reviewing what happened and imagining how the other person might have interpreted it. For some people, this can look like wondering whether they said something awkward, analyzing someone's facial expression, or interpreting a short response as a sign that something is wrong. We might even imagine how a conversation could have gone differently, hoping to prevent an uncomfortable interaction from happening again. In an attempt to find reassurance or certainty, we keep thinking through the interaction. Unfortunately, this often leaves us with more questions than answers. How to Stop Getting Stuck in the Replay The goal is not to prevent yourself from ever thinking about a conversation again. Instead, it is to recognize when your thoughts are no longer helping you and practice responding to them differently. 1. Separate the facts from your assumptions. When you notice yourself replaying an interaction, pause and ask yourself what you actually know. What happened, and what are you interpreting? For example, the fact might be that someone gave a short response to your message. The interpretation might be that they are annoyed with you. There could be many explanations for their response, and you may not have enough information to know which one is true. Reminding yourself of this distinction can help create some distance between what happened and what your anxiety is telling you happened. 2. Make room for uncertainty. One of the hardest parts of overthinking is accepting that you may never know exactly what someone else thought about an interaction. You might want to revisit the conversation, ask for reassurance, or mentally review every detail until you feel certain that everything is okay. Instead, practice letting a question remain unanswered. When you notice yourself wondering, Did they think I was weird?, try responding with, I don't know what they thought, and I can be okay without knowing. This may feel uncomfortable at first. However, learning to tolerate uncertainty can help you spend less time searching for answers that may not be available. 3. Gently redirect your attention. Sometimes, the more we try to force a thought out of our minds, the more it seems to stick around. Rather than criticizing yourself for overthinking or trying to make the thought disappear, acknowledge it and gently bring your attention back to the present. You might take a walk, listen to music, return to a task, or focus on the people and activities around you. The thought may still be there, and that is okay. You can choose to engage with what is happening now without needing to resolve every concern about the past. Giving Yourself Permission to Move On Overthinking conversations often comes from a desire to connect with others and feel accepted. There is nothing wrong with caring about how you are perceived. The difficulty arises when that desire leaves you constantly questioning yourself or feeling as though every interaction needs to be analyzed. The next time you catch yourself replaying a conversation, try pausing before diving back into the details. Ask yourself whether reviewing the interaction is helping you learn something useful or simply keeping you stuck. Remind yourself that a thought is not necessarily a fact, and that you are allowed to move forward without knowing exactly what someone else thinks. References: Edgar, E. V., Richards, A., Castagna, P. J., Bloch, M. H., & Crowley, M. J. (2024). Post-event rumination and social anxiety: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 173, 87–97. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2024.03.013 National Health Service. (2023). Social anxiety (social phobia). https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/social-anxiety/ By Emma Shelton, Taproot Therapy Clinical Trainee
Have you ever received a short text from someone and immediately wondered if they were upset with you? Maybe your boss said, “Can we talk tomorrow?” and your mind instantly jumped to the worst-case scenario. Or maybe you walked into a room and found yourself paying overly close attention to everyone’s expressions, tone of voice, and body language. It’s easy to dismiss these reactions as “overthinking.” But sometimes, they reflect something really reasonable: that our brains learn from experience. When we repeatedly experience stress, especially stress involving uncertainty, criticism, rejection, or feeling unsafe, we become more prepared to encounter those experiences again. Over time, this can shape not only how we feel, but what we notice, expect, and how we interpret unclear situations. Our Expectations Shape What We Notice Our brains are constantly trying to make sense of incomplete information. Most situations don’t come with a clear explanation of what another person is thinking or what will happen next, so we have to use previous experiences to fill in the gaps. Sometimes, that ability is incredibly helpful! If something has been dangerous or painful before, being able to recognize it quickly may help us protect ourselves. However, our expectations can also shape how we interpret more ambiguous situations. Research on rejection sensitivity offers one example. Downey and Feldman (1996) described rejection sensitivity as a tendency to expect, perceive, and strongly react to rejection. In their research, people who anxiously expected rejection were more likely to perceive rejection in ambiguous interpersonal situations. Imagine sending a message to a friend and not hearing back for several hours. There are tons of possible explanations, but if rejection is something you have learned to anticipate, your mind may quickly settle on “they’re ignoring me” as an answer. That conclusion may seem immediate and obvious, even if the situation is still uncertain from an outsider’s perspective. Hypervigilance As a Learned Form of Protection When difficult experiences happen repeatedly, paying close attention to potential warning signs can be protective. Someone who grew up around unpredictable conflict, for example, may become especially attuned to subtle changes in another person's tone. Someone who has repeatedly experienced rejection may notice signs of disapproval that other people overlook. From this perspective, hypervigilance isn't the brain “malfunctioning” or “overreacting.” It is an attempt to predict what might happen next. The difficulty is that hypervigilance strategies developed in one environment don’t always translate. A change in someone's tone might once have reliably signaled an argument. Years later, the same change in tone may still trigger the expectation that conflict is coming even when there are many other possible explanations. Our brains are exceptional at learning patterns, but that means we can be vulnerable to repeating them in uncalled-for situations. Not Every Fear Is Irrational There is an important complication here! Sometimes people anticipate rejection because they have very real reasons to. Meyer's (2003) minority stress model describes how stigma, prejudice, and discrimination can create additional chronic stress for people with marginalized identities. The model includes not only direct experiences of prejudice, but also processes such as expectations of rejection and concealment. If someone who has repeatedly experienced discrimination enters a new environment wondering whether they will be accepted, it would be overly simplistic to label that expectation a “cognitive distortion.” Their expectation is informed by experiences in the world around them. The same principle can apply beyond minority stress. Someone who has experienced repeated criticism, bullying, unstable relationships, or other forms of interpersonal harm may have learned that watching carefully for signs of danger helps protect them. That doesn't mean every prediction will be accurate. But understanding where the prediction came from is often more helpful than simply labeling it as irrational. Avoidance Can Reinforce Expectations Once we expect something to be a threat, our behavior changes.If you expect someone to reject you, you might avoid reaching out. If you expect conflict, you might avoid saying what you really think. If you worry about making a mistake, you might spend hours checking your work. In the short term, avoidance often works. The uncomfortable feeling decreases because we no longer have to face the uncertain situation. But avoidance also makes it harder to learn something new. Research on exposure therapy helps explain why. Craske and colleagues (2014) talk about how treatment is not simply about making fear disappear. Instead, confronting the experiences in small, manageable doses in therapy can help teach your brain to unlearn those unhelpful patterns. By creating opportunities to be proven wrong about our expectations, we are challenging ourselves to grow. If I believe “If I disagree with someone, they will become angry and leave me,” I may avoid disagreement entirely. However, that pattern of behavior stops me from discovering other possibilities. Expressing a small disagreement with someone trustworthy might create a new experience and create new learning opportunities. Therapy Isn't About Convincing Yourself That Everything Is Safe This is one reason therapy can be more nuanced than simply replacing a “negative thought” with a “positive” one. The goal is not to automatically replace “something bad is going to happen” with “everything is fine.” Instead, therapy can create space to become curious about how we reached that prediction in the first place. At Taproot Therapy, we can explore both sides of this process, honoring why a protective response developed while also asking whether it still serves us the same way today. References Craske, M. G., Treanor, M., Conway, C. C., Zbozinek, T., & Vervliet, B. (2014). Maximizing exposure therapy: An inhibitory learning approach. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 58, 10–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2014.04.006 Downey, G., & Feldman, S. I. (1996). Implications of rejection sensitivity for intimate relationships. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 70(6), 1327–1343. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.70.6.1327 Meyer, I. H. (2003). Prejudice, social stress, and mental health in lesbian, gay, and bisexual populations: Conceptual issues and research evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 129(5), 674–697. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.129.5.674 By Kate (Katie) Pargament, Taproot Therapy Clinical Trainee
Have you ever gone through a period where things that normally feel easy suddenly take so much more effort? Maybe you're having trouble concentrating, feeling more irritable than usual, or finding yourself exhausted even after getting a full night's sleep. You might start questioning why you're feeling this way, especially when nothing significant in your life has changed. What we don't always recognize is that our mental health can be affected by changes happening around us, including the seasons. As we move into the colder months, some people experience changes in their mood and energy that go beyond simply disliking winter. This can sometimes be a sign of seasonal depression. Seasonal Depression Doesn't Always Look Like Sadness Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) is a type of depression that follows a seasonal pattern, most commonly beginning in the fall or winter and improving in the spring. While sadness is often associated with depression, it isn't necessarily the first thing people notice. For some, it might be difficulty getting motivated, withdrawing from conversations, feeling overwhelmed by responsibilities, or losing interest in things they normally look forward to. According to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), seasonal depression can also involve changes in sleep, appetite, concentration, and energy levels. The challenge is that these symptoms can be easy to overlook. We might convince ourselves we're just tired, stressed, or going through a busy period without recognizing that something more could be happening. When We Start Being Harder on Ourselves Something I think is particularly important to recognize is how easily changes in our mental health can turn into negative thoughts about ourselves. When you're struggling to find motivation or accomplish the things you normally would, it's easy to become frustrated with yourself. You might start thinking you're being lazy, that you're falling behind, or that you should be doing more. But there's a difference between not wanting to do something and genuinely struggling to find the energy to do it. Depression can affect concentration, energy, decision-making, and how we perceive ourselves. When these things change, continuing to hold ourselves to the exact same expectations can create even more frustration. Instead of immediately criticizing yourself for feeling less productive, it may be worth asking why certain things have started feeling more difficult. Understanding What's Happening Researchers believe seasonal depression is associated with changes in daylight that can affect our body's internal clock and systems involved in regulating mood and sleep. However, not every change in mood during the winter means someone has Seasonal Affective Disorder. Stress, life transitions, and other mental health concerns can also affect how we feel during this time of year. One thing that can be helpful is paying attention to patterns. Are these feelings new, or do they tend to happen around the same time every year? Have you noticed changes in how you're sleeping, interacting with others, or managing responsibilities? Recognizing these changes can help you better understand what you're experiencing rather than dismissing it. You Don't Have to Wait Until Spring to Feel Better One misconception about seasonal depression is that because it is temporary, we just have to push through it until the weather changes. But experiencing symptoms during a particular season doesn't make them any less important. There are effective treatment options for seasonal depression, including psychotherapy, light therapy, and, in some cases, medication. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy adapted for seasonal depression (CBT-SAD) can help individuals address negative thought patterns and behaviors that may be contributing to their symptoms. Treatment is not one-size-fits-all, and speaking with a mental health professional can help you determine what kind of support may be most beneficial. Light therapy, in particular, should be discussed with a healthcare professional because it may not be appropriate for everyone. Even if you're unsure whether what you're experiencing is seasonal depression, you don't need a diagnosis to start talking about how you've been feeling. Giving Yourself Permission to Acknowledge It There is often an unspoken expectation to justify or explain personal difficulties. We want to be able to point to a particular event, relationship, or circumstance and say that's the reason we're not feeling like ourselves. But mental health doesn't always work that way. Sometimes recognizing that something has changed, even when we can't fully explain it, is an important first step. Therapy can be a space to better understand these changes, explore the thoughts and emotions that come with them, and find ways to support yourself through difficult periods. Just because your symptoms may be seasonal doesn't mean you have to face them on your own. Sources:
By Natasha Stein, Taproot Therapy Clinical Trainee
Have you ever had a perfectly good Sunday afternoon suddenly interrupted by the thought of Monday? Maybe you start thinking about everything you need to do at work, the emails waiting for you, an upcoming meeting, or everything on your to-do list. Before you know it, you're no longer enjoying your weekend, you're already worrying about tomorrow. If this sounds familiar, you've probably experienced the "Sunday Scaries." While the phrase is often used casually, the anxiety behind it is very real. The Sunday Scaries are a form of anticipatory anxiety: the worry or distress we experience when thinking about something that hasn't happened yet. Our brains are constantly trying to predict what's coming next. When something feels uncertain, stressful, or outside of our control, our minds may start running through different possibilities in an attempt to prepare us. The problem is that preparation can quickly turn into overthinking. Instead of simply thinking, "I have work tomorrow," your mind might jump to what if I can't get everything done or what if this week is overly busy? Nothing has actually happened yet, but your body may respond as though you are already dealing with the situation. Staying present One of the hardest parts of anticipatory anxiety is that it can pull us out of the moment we're actually in. You might spend your Sunday thinking about Monday, your evening worrying about tomorrow, or the days leading up to an appointment imagining everything that could go wrong. If there is something you can do, take one small step. Write down what you need to remember, prepare what you can, or make a plan for tomorrow. If there isn't anything you can do right now, give yourself permission to return to the present. Anticipatory anxiety often comes from wanting certainty. We want to know that everything will go smoothly before we allow ourselves to relax. But we can't always know how something will unfold. Instead of trying to predict every possible outcome, try reminding yourself that you know exactly how it will go, but you can handle it when it gets here. You don't have to spend your entire Sunday preparing emotionally for Monday. You don't have to experience every difficult possibility before it happens. Sometimes, the most helpful thing you can do is let tomorrow be tomorrow and give yourself permission to be where you are today. If anticipatory anxiety is becoming a regular part of your life or interfering with your sleep, relationships, work, or ability to enjoy your time, it may be worth exploring what is underneath the worry. You don't have to navigate it alone. Sources: Tips to tame the “Sunday scaries.” Cleveland Clinic. (n.d.). https://my.clevelandclinic.org/podcasts/health-essentials/tips-to-tame-the-sunday-scaries Ways to curb the Sunday scaries. Emerson Health. (2025, March 3). https://emersonhealth.org/ways-to-curb-the-sunday-scaries/ |
Categories
All
Archives
November 2026
|
|
|